Thursday, September 27, 2007

But How Will She Ever Hear The Gambler?

It was when Jason asked this that I realized how ill-equipped we were for the task. He had proposed that we compile a sort of "greatest hits" of our lifetime for Nora's benefit. I'm still unsure if he intends this to be an album of songs that we think are great or if they merely reflect the soundtrack of the time of our childhood/teens/young adult years. I guess more of the latter, since she will have access to our music collection and is already listening to it all the time. Anyway dear readers, it is clear that we are not up to the task, since after 2 hours of discussion and a great deal of lost sleep and insidious ear-worms, we still don't have a list. Nor are we even sure that this can be a single compilation, but perhaps a series of compilations - perhaps done by decades or in the footsteps of the great call now! infomercials, there could be an arena rock disc, a disco disc, a country disc, a metal disc, a Europop disc etc. Clearly we need your help. We welcome suggestions for how this project should be organized as well. Possible candidates already tossed into the ring include: the afore mentioned Kenny Rogers standard, Big Country's Big Country, David Bowie's, Space Odyssey, Led Zepplin's When the Levee Breaks, The Cure's Love Cats, Cindy Lauper's Girls Just Want To Have Fun, REM's Driver 8, The Police's Message in a Bottle, Paul Simon's Graceland or Diamonds on the Soles of Her Shoes, Nina's 99Luftbaloons, KC and the Sunshine Band's Shake your Booty, and a gazillion others have been tossed about. We've agreed that no Rush or Styx will be included but we are in debate over whether Boston's More Than a Feelin' has a place. Jason is adamant that Trio's Da Da Da be included. Obviously there are some gaping holes. We can't decide on which Bob Marley and Indigo Girls need to be included and the Pogue's are lyrically problematic so we'll wait on them till she's older. Fortunately, Jason has not insisted on Hall and Oats. We know several of you have opinions on this already, so start posting.

8 comments:

Murfmensch said...

"When the Levee Breaks" by Led Zeppelin.

(Other LZ lyrics would be a bit strange to be commended by one's parents. She will end up hearing Hairway to Steven.)

Murfmensch said...

The question:

Is this mix supposed to testify to her parents musical tastes? or:

Ought this mix catalogue great music of the past?

If the former, then the fact that Hall and Oates were my fave band in junior high (mortifying) would bring -Private Eyes- into the mix.

TP said...

See, I think you'll have to be subtle if you want her to actually listen to it. I associate astonishingly bad 8 tracks with my parents taste in music. Actually, to be honest there are songs on all those old 8 tracks that I'm still fond of, but it was mostly because it was music that they listened to rather than anything they wanted me to care about. (The parentals have decidedly unformed musical taste).

You would probably do better to simply have the music you listen to, plus a few compilation discs of the type that you mention which you, too, listen to. And I would suggest music that was great, but wouldn't show up in your other tunes. So, yeah, you should include Hem, but that's something you're already playing. An extra compilation disc provides the education you want and would include tunes you don't own or play the albums for...

As to particular bits and my votes,
-"More Than A Feelin'" belongs
-Lauper's "Girls" -yes, but also and more importantly "Time After Time"
-"Driver 8" but also "Cuyahoga"
-Police "Message in a Bottle" but also "De Doo Doo Doo" - because what better singalong for the toddler set.
-Marley "Could you be loved" and "Redemption Song" work even young. "I Shot The Sheriff" when she's in early grade school is probably fine.
-Indigo (of course I have an opinion about this) Now and up "Closer to Fine," "Hammer and Nail," and "Galileo"... and "Shame on You" are all fine and fun. For the toddler set, those are probably the happier tunes.

Going back a bit (and not strictly toddler, but mostly),
-Chic "Good Times"
-George Benson "Turn Your Love Around"
-Parliament "Flashlight"
-Kool & The Gang "Jungle Boogie"
-Kate Bush "This Woman's Work"
-The Pretenders "Brass in Pocket"
-Sarah McLachlan "Ice Cream"
-Curtis Mayfield "Superfly"
-Isaac Hayes "Shaft"
-Bee Gees "Night Fever" ... yes, I said it...
-O'Jays "Love Train"
-Earth Wind and Fire "Let's Groove" and "September"
-Dylan "All Along the Watchtower"
-Fleetwood Mac "Dreams"
-Stevie Nicks "Rhiannon" and "Edge of Seventeen"
-Pixies "Gigantic"
-Van Morrison "Moondance"
-Manilow "Copacabana" ... back off, okay... you were about to put Private Eyes in the mix.... though you know that Sarah Smile should be in it... I'm just sayin'.

And now I'm going through the iTunes catalog in my head... blast you.

Anonymous said...

What about sometihng from your very first album that you ever got? For me, that would have to be something from (gasp) Duran Duran's Seven and the Ragged Tiger album. My sister's first album was Joan Jett and the Blackhearts,and, since we had to share a stereo, I heard that a lot more than I ever did Duran Duran... but I'm not sure that anything from either of those would be that Noralicious.

TP said...

Tree- I can top your Seven with a purchase of Rio before that... but the first album I owned was... Debby Boone "You Light Up My Life", now that's embarrassing. The first that I paid for myself Asia's "Asia."

I guess I was just caught up in the "Heat of the Moment," but that would be a fun compilation disc to put together. Songs from the first album bought by the parentals, the grandparentals, etc. Maybe I'm just getting psyched up to teach High Fidelity this term.

Murfmensch said...

Is it me or is "Rio" and Asia less embarassing that Hall and Oates?

These lists have been outstanding.

I will add "Free" by Cat Power to the mix.

magpie said...

I'm not sure what my first album was. I think Columbia House might have had something to do with it, so then there would have been 6-7 at one time. (expect for the MASH soundtrack my parents had and that I listened to continually as first grader - yes I was a strange kid). Anyway, those first albums included: Men At Work, Stevie Nicks, Asia (me too!) and Journey.

Murfmensch said...

"Intergalactic" by the Beastie Boyz.